Spring City briefed on potential dark skies ordinance
By Suzanne Dean
SPRING CITY—The Spring City Council, along with residents who were present at the Nov. 5 meeting, considered whether the town should join Ephraim and Moroni in adopting a dark skies ordinance.
Councilman Chris Anderson said when the possibility of such an ordinance had been presented earlier in the year, questions were raised about whether a dark-skies program would contribute to crime or create expense for residents.
So Anderson invited Matthias Schmitt of LaVerkin in Washington County, an astronomer who Anderson said had “been through the process and understands the process” of implementing dark skies programs, to brief the council.
Schmitt, a native of Germany, lived in New York City for 20 years. During those years, “I had no idea how big the night skies are,” he said.
After visiting Oregon, where he witnessed an eclipse of the sun, “my life changed,” he said. He got a master’s degree in astronomy and now teaches astronomy at Southern Utah University and College of Southern Nevada.
He said he moved to Utah largely because it was a place where he could view the splendor of the night sky.
Anyone who sees the Milky Way for the first time “comes back with a sense of wonder and awe,” he said. And, he said, Utah has more locations meeting dark sky criteria than any other place in the world. “This is a treasure mine for Utah.”
Schmitt listed some of the characteristics and requirements for becoming a dark sky community:
- Outdoor lighting must point to the ground and have shielding over the top to prevent light from traveling toward the sky.
- The lighting should be “a warm, glowing amber color” rather than white.
- If people have outside fixtures that are not dark-sky compliant, they typically have 5-7 years to install new fixtures. At any point after passage of a dark-sky ordinance, if a light needs to be replaced, the new light must be dark-sky-compliant.
- When old lights are replaced, the new lights will nearly always be energy-efficient LED lights.
- If residents are concerned about safety, they can install motion sensors that turn on lights if there is movement on the property.
“All these things combine to reduce the impact on your wallet,” he said. “A properly directed light means you use less energy, so it’s cheaper.”
Schmitt said excessive night light creates a glare that reduces visibility, making it more difficult to see an intruder.
He showed a slide of a person hiding in a doorway on a brightly lit street. The person was barely visible. He showed a second slide where light was dimmer. “All of a sudden,” he said, “you can see there’s actually a person standing there in that door frame.”
Numerous studies have been conducted on the relationship between lighting and crime, he said. “I can tell you the evidence is mixed.”
When bright light towers were added in public housing complexes in New York City, the crime rate dropped 36 percent, he said.
Yet, he said, the National Institute for Crime Prevention says “effective lighting is not about maximum illumination. It is about appropriate illumination.” He said there are plenty of studies where better lighting was installed and there was no change in the incidence of crime.
Both Ephraim and Moroni passed their dark sky ordinances in 2024.
Many of the towns in Utah that have bought into the dark sky concept are smaller towns, including Helper in Carbon County, Torrey in Wayne County, Kanab in Kane County and Springdale in Washington County.
Schmitt said walking through such towns gives him “a sense of connectedness to history.” “You want to keep Main Street looking like Main Street. You want to keep that historic glow. If you could stand on Main Street and see the stars, that would be awesome.”
Kimberly Stewart, a resident, said when she moved to Spring City, there were no street lights on Main Street. Then the city installed bright lights. People began to refer to the street as “the landing strip.”
Since then, she said, the city has installed new lights that are more subtle.
Kent Kummer, the Spring City power superintendent, said that because Main Street is a state road, it is subject to a requirement that at night, there must be a certain level of illumination in the middle of the street.
He said Spring City had changed out all its street lights to LED lights. The lights have both white light and yellow light options. Currently, the city is using white light. But switching to amber is just a matter of “going to each light and dropping the other light down. If the whole town wants to do that, we can switch them all.”
But he added, “Bear in mind council, if you drop that color down, there might be another person who wants the white lights.”
Schmitt said the goal of his visit was to be “a starting point for discussion.”
Anderson said the council would consult with Schmitt on “a good format to start with” in developing a proposed ordinance.


